I bought this trilogy on a whim as they were 99p each in one of Amazon's monthly sales and I'm so glad I did.
On reflection, I revised my rating down from 3 stars to 2.5. I found the story hard to get into but then it suddenly got going, a couple of chapters in and I started to enjoy it. However, the pace wasn't sustained and I ended up finding the whole thing patchy, overly long and tedious by the end (I found I was skim-reading the last 100 pages a bit just to get it finished and find out whodunnit and why). A shame, because I loved the original SH stories and hoped that this might be a series worth pursuing. I doubt that I'll bother with any more of them though.
Update: 8/9/13 I've enjoyed working on this but after having completed 46 of the 72 alterations, I think it's time to give it a rest for a while.
4.5 stars. I found the first few chapters of this book rather frustrating and uncomfortable to read. Sarah's incredibly busy, multitasking, impatient, high-powered lifestyle is completely at odds with how I choose to live my own life and I felt myself getting stressed, anxious and angry just reading about her typical, nonstop, high pressure day. It was almost a relief when she had the accident and was forced to slow down.
Aargh! I typed out a review and it obviously didn't save - darn you, Goodreads app!
I read Noughts and Crosses several years ago and remember really enjoying it but never got around to reading the rest of the series. I did try to give this one a go but couldn't get into it. No rating.
Ugh! This is the third book I've abandoned in as many weeks. I don't know whether I'm just not in the mood for a particular genre, I'm too distracted to get into a book properly or whether I'm just picking bad books but it's unusual for me to abandon so many at once.
I persevered with this because of the overwhelmingly positive reviews and ratings, both here and on Amazon UK, but it really wasn't my cup of tea.
3.5 stars. Good but not great and definitely not a patch on Still Alice, which I read earlier this year. It was a bit patchy and a little unbelievable. Having said that, I do enjoy Lisa's writing style and will definitely read more of her work.
I borrowed this from the library after I saw it had won the Waterstones Children's Book Prize, expecting a good read. However, I got to page 90 and decided I'd had enough. I didn't like the subject matter or the way it was written and wasn't interested enough in the outcome to slog through another couple of hundred odd pages.
Update 11/3/13 - downgrading this to 3.5 stars. I did like it but I don't think it deserved to be rated the same as Hollow Earth, to which I awarded 4*
Loved it! Such a charming story, I enjoyed it from start to finish. I actually enjoyed it more than The Secret Garden, which I read for the first time last year.
1